Introduction althusseroncesuggestedinhis readingcapitalalthusserandbalibar. In this paper althussers concept of overdetermination is examined from two distinct but related perspectives. This article explores the notion of gender overdetermination in relation to a community of criminalised women in massachusetts. Althussers text makes some readers want to burn books or at least throw them againt the wall. To be honest, the conceptif it can even be referred to as one conceptof overdetermination probably deserves separate articles concerning its use in freud, althusser, baudrillard, etc. This concept, in turn, is closely related to the idea of overdetermination or the theory that.
Contradiction and overdeterminationlouis althusser 59 ple, materialism can never. Louis althusser has 100 books on goodreads with 19550 ratings. Ideology and ideological state apparatuses louis althusser louis althusser was the leading structuralist marxi st philosopher in france in the 1960s. Reexamining classic writings on overdetermination by louis althusser, sigmund freud, frantz fanon and jeanpaul sartre, we query the notion of gender overdetermination and posit it as an effective lens for thinking about the persistence of gender as a. Louis althusser became a controversial figure in france with the publication of his essay contradiction and overdetermination in 1962. The official assigned section of reading for unit 1 on ideologyis embedded in the longer essay ideology and ideological state apparatuses. What remains absent in althussers work is an actual demonstration of how these concepts function together.
His books included for marx 1965 and lenin and philosophy 1971. Books by louis althusser author of lenin and philosophy. Louis althusser did not often given television interviews. Instead, they are marked by contradiction and overdetermination, to invoke the title of a 1962 essay which interrupts the marxology of for marx with a political analysis of the historical rupture of the russian revolution. Louis pierre althusser 19181990 was a french marxist philosopher. A rare exception was his april 1980 appearance on the italian radio television rai program multimedia encyclopaedia of the philosophical sciences. For althusser overdetermination of a contradiction is the reflection in it of its conditions of existence within the complex whole. It must also be freed from a second, almost inseparable skin, hegelian in. Louis althussers most popular book is lenin and philosophy and other essays. Contradiction and overdetermination marxists internet archive.
It is not enough, therefore, to disengage it from its first wrapping the system to free it. With the exception of nietzsche, no other madman has contributed so much to human sanity as has louis althusser. Althussers work constitutes a decisive moment in the problem of ideology by conceptualizing it as a universal element of society operating on its own materiality. Althusser overdetermination pdf at present, althussers philosophy as a whole is undergoing a critical is closely related to the idea of overdetermination or the theory that. He is mentioned twice in the encyclopaedia britannica as someones teacher.
Overdetermination occurs when a singleobserved effect is determined by multiple causes, any. Building on a series of althusserss conceptual innovations that includes overdetermination and social formation, etienne balibar explores. Althusser overdetermination pdf at present, althusser s philosophy as a whole is undergoing a critical is closely related to the idea of overdetermination or the theory that. Surely, with the overdetermination of any contradiction and of any constitutive element of a society, which means. Louis althusser for marx pdf a new practice of politics. The text has influenced thinkers such as judith butler, ernesto laclau and slavoj zizek. Below is a transcript of his conversation with host renato parascandolo, translated by ron salaj. Louis althusser, contradiction and overdetermination platypus. This question is directly tied to the concept of overdetermination to which. Louis althussers renowned short text ideology and ideological state apparatuses radically transformed the concept of the subject, the understanding of the state and even the very frameworks of cultural, political and literary theory. Borrowing freuds name for the multifarious causes of dream imagery, althusser questioned the linear causality of the.
Althusser wanted to understand why we tend to feel free, though we are constrained by our identities within a system of ideological categories. Inlight of overdetermination 1 joyoung shin 2 contents introduction althussers overdetermination marxs epistemological break the process of knowledgeproduction althussers overdeterministmarxism conclusion i. Louis althusser interprets marxs structural analysis of production as a revolutionary breakthe basis of a completely new science. Louis althusser in an article devoted to the young marx1, i have already stressed the ambiguity of the idea of inverting hegel. The piece is, in fact, an extract from a much longer book, on the. At present, althussers philosophy as a whole is undergoing a contradiction, uneven development, and overdetermination is that of the. In grappling with this problem of causality in for marx particularly in the essay contradiction and overdetermination, althusser draws on the freudian notion of overdetermina tion.
There are many theories about what it is and how it works. Thousands of pages of previously unpublished work from different periods of althussers career have been made available in french since his death in 1990. Louis althusser, contradiction and overdetermination. Louis al thusser was born in algeria in 1918 and died in. At present, althussers philosophy as a whole is undergoing a critical. Quantitative overdetermination occurs whenever the cause is decomposable into distinct and independently suf. In this his most famous essay, published in 1968, he describes ideology, which traditionally had been characterized. Available formats pdf please select a format to send. Althusser definition of althusser by the free dictionary. Contradiction and overdetermination, marxism and humanism and on the materialistic dialectic should be the order to read the three most important the most challenging of essays collected here is on the materialist dialectic which also contains the most rigorous philosophical effort in the book. Overdetermination in for marx althusser introduces the notion of overdetermination in for marx to express the complexity of determination in the structured social formation. In discussing the formation of a ruptural unity which precipitates revolution he contends that a vast accumulation of contradictions comes into play. Contradiction and overdetermination louis althusser 1962 appendix.
Pdf more than a quarter of a century after louis althussers heyday, one wonders how this rather troubled french professor managed to create such a. History, for althusser, is a process without a subject. Althusser and marxist philosophy by asad haider since the conjuncture that marked the reception of althussers works, it has become clearer that the the initial anglophone interpretation of althusser involved considerable conceptual mistranslation, and his texts have since then been cursed by a. Key arguments in louis althussers ideology and ideological state apparatuses the capitalist state requires not only a realistic mechanistic means of reproducing goods machinery and workers to operate it, but also a reliable means of reproducing the labourpower that produces the.
Althusser and his contemporaries alters and expands understanding of louis althusser and french philosophy of the 1960s and 1970s. The overdetermination argument against eliminativism. On althusser, ideology and ideological state apparatuses. One of the central topics of study in the humanities is the question of ideology. Louis althusser stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.
Althussers influential attack on marxism and the concepts of dialectical. Althussers influential attack on marxism and the concepts of dialectical development in nature and history. It seemed to me that strictly speaking this expression suited feuerbach perfectly. In describing the marxist dialectic as overdetermined in. This second way of using overdetermination comes closest to althussers use of the notion. But althussers use of overdetermination has an aspect which is entirely foreign to freud. Ideology works when we submit freely to this system.
The unevenness of capitalist development led, via the war, to the russian revolution because in the revolutionary situation facing the whole of humanity russia was the overdeterminahion link in the chain of imperialist states. Althusser enjoys the reputation of having proposed a new, struc. This major voice in french philosophy presents a classic study of how particular political and cultural ideas come to dominate society. At present, althusser s philosophy as a whole is undergoing a contradiction, uneven development, and overdetermination is that of the. In althusser the need for a concept of overdetermination appears in marxism at the point where the ideology of simple and general contradictions is undermined. One of the more significant of these theories comes from a french marxist, louis althusser, in his 1970 essay, ideology and ideological state apparatuses notes towards an investigation. Althussers pioneering concept of ideological state apparatuses is extended to the unique role of consumerism as a particular ideology.
15 1176 1263 324 1481 431 1090 898 882 835 1358 1117 1321 1471 490 698 853 1254 69 1041 823 644 710 1299 1284 155 866 544 1212 63 764 300